A most intriguing post by Mike Elgan over at CultofMac is here, where he asserts that every child in the US needs an iPad. His arguments revolve around the benefits of an interactive device in the hands of a child as opposed to the one way mind feeding that a television set offers. Some quotes:
Everybody’s asking: Are iPads healthy for children?
I’m here to tell you: That’s the wrong question.
The right question is this: Is the iPad a healthy *replacement* for TV? And I believe the answer is a resounding yes.
The iPad is scary because it’s new. But most parents have already accepted a gigantic role for something truly in the lives of their children: television. The content kids see on their TV sets is mostly mind-numbing, soul-deadening, formulaic consumerist crap, punctuated by sophisticated ad campaigns designed to transform children into mindless consumers.
…
Kids spend more time watching TV than they do in class (1,500 hours on TV per year vs. 900 hours in school).
…
I could go on for pages. The bottom line is that TV is a massive, negative, toxic, unhealthy influence in the lives of American children. I think parents already know this.
The solution, Elgan states, is to offer children an interactive device with far less commercial content and mind numbing one way interaction to children.
That’s why fearing the iPad is such a colossal error. The iPad isn’t a new problem. The iPad is a new solution to an old problem.
By *replacing* TV time with iPad use, parents can dramatically improve the lives of their children.
From a parent’s perspective, the iPad is superior to a TV in every significant way:
* The iPad has far fewer, far less harmful ads than TV. It can even be rendered “commercial-free.” Imagine that.
* The iPad is interactive, for the most part, rather than passive. Instead of just staring motionless at TV, kids could be solving puzzles, actively playing games, typing, drawing and other activities.
Yes, even the simplest games on an iPad are far more interactive than any TV show. It’s a good article, and Elgan concludes by encouraging parents to buy iPads for their children as soon as possible. His points merit consideration, and the digerati are taking him seriously. Hopefully others will, too.